6-month , 1,000 pt Trading Range in the Dow gives lots of opportunity for finger pointing

Watching the chatter class on cable, its easy to get caught up in their mindless ramblings.  Sell off -Terrible. Rally- Party hats and Champagne for all!  The repetition is sometimes mind numbing.  Bad news always gets more attention. In a country of 340Million people, it seems as though there are 339 million eager to be able to say “see, I told you so”,  when the market sells off.

I am a big fan of listening to both the conservative AM entertainers as well as the “progressive ” left wingers. Each one has their own perverse ideology.  It always boils down to blaming sell-off’s on “the other side”.  I listened to Smiley and West several months ago and they were both bemoaning the “massive trillions of wealth” lost during the stock market panic of 2009.  The seemed oblivious to the fact that all of those losses and then some had been gained back.  The lows were traceable to Reagan, Bush/Cheney, as if the 8 yrs of Clinton/Gore saw a suspension of any policies which could ever have lead to any of the problems which sparked 2009.

Conversly,  listening to the right wingers,  the recent 1,000 pt swings lower were All attributable to one person, POTUS.   All attributable to the ACA (Obama care) and all somehow easily blamed on one person.  Its just as ridiculous as when one side does it as the other if you ask me.

Skewed logic on both ends if you ask me.   However, it gives a person with no real ideological bent a great key as to when markets are turning.

Right now, if you look at the chart below, we’ve had a 1,000 pt trading range for the past 6 months in the Dow futures.  I use the Dow , because, although 90 percent of traders look at the S&P because its a broader index,  I have found that for a psychological read on the country, the Dow average, for better or worse is a more meaningful guage. Bottom line its my personal preference given my history of having spent 7 years trading that Dow index back when the open outcry pits were in place.
Yes, there is a ton of correlation between the S&P 500.  Yes you can use one to trade off the other.  I am aware of all that.  I am just explaining why I concentrate on the Dow.

We have been between 14,600 and 15,600 for the past 6 months.  Look at the Daily chart of December Dow below:  

 
A 1,000 point move from 14,600 higher is a 6.8% move.  A 1,000 point move from 15,600 is a 6.4% fluctuation.
 
This is a key point.  Despite the hand wringing from the chatter class,  they all neglect to talk about percentage moves. 
 
Its much more scary and enticing to say  “we had a 1,000 pt drop and its the other guy’s fault”,  lol
 
Remember, back in 2009 with the dow at 6500?   1000 point move from there was a 15% move.  Remember the media trotting out the perma bears calling for dow 100?  That was a sign the fear bottom was in.  However, having been trading then, I can tell you it took a big gulp of cold water to step in and buy more down there.  which is why most folks, if you pulled their trading sheets,  would be lying to you if they said they bought the bottom.  If they did, its most likely because they bought  it at 6500 after buying it at 14,000, 13,500, 13,000,  12,500, 12,000, etc etc.
 
I am keeping a watchful eye on the horizons for the new bulls to emerge, calling once again for Dow 25K or Dow 30K.  That will be the sign we have gotten strung out to the buy side.   For now, honestly,  I’d be looking at this trading range in the Dow as nothing more than that.
 
WE are nearing the top and as we get towards the top, I’d be looking to establish shorts. or I’d be buying cheep puts to protect any stock gains if you don’t want to sell them to take profits.
 
15,200 to 15,600 is a pretty wide window to be trying to catch a break.  But honestly, until we break above the next big round number at 16,000…  I think that’s the best way to play it. If you are long, make sure you are buying put protection to cover your long winnings.
No one, and I mean no one  really knows how high we can go…. However,  remember,  markets tend to go down, or drop  3 times as fast as it takes to rally them up.  Its the drop on the roller coaster ride that makes everyone ill. 
 
CER
 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *